This is Your First Step Towards Success.

Let's create work together! We LOVE working with new clients on exciting challenges. Please share your ideas in the form below, and we’ll respond within 48 hours of receiving the inquiry.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Increase your website conversions with these changes

I’m Driving More Traffic to my Website, but It’s Not Resulting in More Conversions

If you’re investing heavily to drive leads to your website with Google Ads and Facebook Ad Manager, BUT, the increase in your spending is not resulting in an increase in sales or qualified leads (conversions) – this one is for you.

Follow along as our team goes through The Top Ten Reasons Your Website is Not Converting to help you on your journey to a better bottom line!

The Top Reasons Your Website is Not Converting

1. You’re Not Measuring Your Website Conversion Rate!

What are website conversions? Website conversions are actions that can be measured to help you achieve your business goals. These actions might include:

  • product purchases (sales)
  • phone call clicks
  • form submissions
  • brochure downloads
  • newsletter sign-ups

To measure improvement, we must first establish a baseline for conversions. To establish this baseline we might track goals in Google Analytics or another analytics platform of your choosing.

After the redesign, organic search traffic grew by 12% and phone call clicks went up by 20%.

Citrus-O

2. You’re Sending the Wrong Visitors to Your Website!

High-quality traffic is driven by strong Digital Marketing strategies. Without SEO, and Paid Advertising, It’s unlikely that you will achieve the traffic necessary to increase sales.

SEO (Search Engine Optimization): SEO is the process of improving your website so that it has the ability to rank on search engine results pages. SEO strategies include keyword research, content creation, content marketing, page keyword optimization, page speed optimization and submitting your sitemap for indexing.

Paid Advertising: consists of paid advertisements across search, advertising networks, and social platforms. There are numerous ways to drive traffic to your website with this strategy. Tactics include search ads, display ads, video ads, shopping ads and in-app ads.

Ensure you are driving the right traffic to your website by using conversion-based advertising strategies. Ensure the message you share in your marketing is in alignment with the content on your landing pages.

3. You Built Your Website for You, Instead of Your Customers!

We see this one a lot: “I don’t like this colour”, “Can we use my favourite font”, “This product should be displayed first”. These are decisions that need to be dictated by user data, not personal preference. You will miss conversion opportunities if your website is not built for your unique users.

4. Your Website is too Complicated!

Website visitors that are given too many choices are unlikely to convert. Put your users on rails with a guided experience called a “User Journey”. Effective User Journeys are intuitive and guide the user through the process from discovery to conversion in an efficient and effective manner.

Typical user journeys for two distinct user types and where a conversion typically occurs.

5. You’re Not Prompting Your Website Visitors to Take Action!

Well-planned user journeys, with distinct calls to action, inform your users what they are supposed to do next. Calls to Action (CTAs) are prompts that encourage the user to take the next step in their journey to conversion. Some examples of CTAs include: “Buy Now!”, “Sign Up Today!” or “Connect with an Advisor!”

Calls to Action like this one provide a place for website conversions.

6. Your Website is Too Slow!

Conversion rates are directly affected by a website’s performance. The faster your webpage loads, the higher the conversion rate. Walmart found that for every 1-second improvement in page load time, conversions increased by 2%. Think about your current sales and your site speed; can you imagine how your performance might be affecting your bottom line? Additionally, studies have shown about 47% of consumers expect websites to load in two seconds or less and that 79% of users would not return to a website that performs poorly. Users are impatient. Improve your site speed!

Full performance test of the Hammerhead website.

7. Your Product and Service Pages Do Not Convey Value!

We establish value in two ways:

Price: Establish value to your customers by providing rock-bottom prices, or timely sales when the data dictates the users will be shopping.

Differentiation: You know your product is the best, but how do you get this point across? This is where branding, high-quality images, product descriptions, use-case videos,  and reviews help showcase value.

Choose a Price or Differentiation strategy, not both. Ensure your branding, marketing material, advertising, and digital strategy are in alignment with this value proposition.

8. Your Checkout Process is Difficult!

Is it intuitive for users to add an additional item to their cart? Can discounts easily applied at checkout? Can users mix and match products? A difficult shopping experience or checkout process is often the root cause of a low conversion rate. Check out our eCommerce services if you are interested in updating your eCommerce website!

If you are sure you have a simple checkout process in place, consider adding abandoned cart features to remind users they have items in their basket.

User flow diagram and feature prioritization list for a UI & UX study to increase website conversions.

9. You’re Providing a Terrible Mobile Experience!

Mobile user-ship has been on the rise for years. It is probable that most of your users are visiting your website from a mobile device. You need to ensure these users have a great experience. Design and performance are of the utmost importance: 

  1. Provide your users with an efficient mobile design.
  2. Ensure your website performs well on mobile. If your website is slow on desktop, it’s going to be even worse on a mobile network with limited reception.

“Effective landing pages are key to getting conversions from your Google Ads traffic. In retail, we’ve seen that a one-second delay in mobile can impact mobile conversions by up to 20%.”

Google Ads Group, 2020

10. You’re Not Capturing Data for Iterations!

Your website was AMAZING in 2019, but your online sales are starting to level off or drop this quarter. This happens! The standard of service is constantly changing online, you need to keep pace or your potential customers will go elsewhere. Website development decisions need to be data-driven. Ensure you are tracking user data in an appropriate manner and split testing revisions and iterations.

Need Website Conversions Help? We’re Here for That!

So how do you know if you’re guilty of one or more of the aforementioned offences? Well for quick and dirty analysis you can use tools like GT Metrix to point your developer in the right direction. For a more thorough analysis, we offer our Website Audit service to identify issues, and our Conversion Rate Optimization service to resolve the identified problems with your website. Connect with us to start your project today!

Evan Holmgren
Evan Holmgren

I am a Co-founder and the Sales & Marketing Director at Hammerhead. We built a team of experienced digital marketers, web designers and programmers who specialize in audience-first experiences to drive conversions and help you succeed online. If you're looking for a strong dedicated digital team, look no further!

Articles: 58

Are You Ready to Start a Conversation?

We want to hear your ideas! Let's start a project together today!

Let's Work Together

Free Knowledge

Learn with Us

We are also here to help you learn! Check out our resources page to learn about digital marketing, design, digital strategy and eCommerce. Part of our growth is empowering you to grow digital as well!

Not Quite Ready?

That's okay! Feel free to browse around learn more.

  • How Many Loonies Do I Need For A Website in Canada

    How Many Loonies Do I Need for a Website?

    April 4, 2025
    ​Creating a website is a crucial step for Canadian businesses aiming to establish a robust online presence. The cost of developing a website can vary significantly based on factors such as complexity, design preferences, functionality, and the expertise of the development team. Understanding these variables is essential for making informed decisions that align with your […]
    /
  • Hammerhead Named Among the Top WordPress Development Companies of 2023

    Hammerhead Named Among the Top WordPress Development Companies of 2024 by Techreviewer.co

    January 18, 2024
    Hammerhead, one of the top WordPress development companies leading web development agencies, is proud to announce its recognition as one of the Top WordPress Developers in 2024 by Techreviewer.co, a highly reputed IT market research and analysis company. Hammerhead’s outstanding services have also earned the firm a spot in the list of top 100 companies. […]
    /
  • Top 5 CMS in 2022

    The Top 5 CMS to Achieve Your Business Goals in 2024

    January 15, 2024
    Choosing a Content Management System (CMS) can be a daunting task. Each year we are greeted with more and more, but what CMS will help you achieve your business and marketing goals? This article will help you narrow it down. What are Business Goals? Business goals are targets that you set for your company. These […]
    /